Everyone has a version of Italy they’ve dreamed about. Sipping wine overlooking the rolling hills of Tuscany. The impossibly blue water surrounding a glamorous island where everything feels like it was designed to make you feel underdressed and slightly overwhelmed in the best possible way. Or ending the day with a cold glass of a limoncello in Sorrento. Whatever your dream may be, you are in the company of millions of others looking for the perfect Italy itinerary and landing on Florence, Sorrento and Capri.
This itinerary combines Renaissance art, dramatic coastlines and island luxury in a single trip. On paper it sounds like the perfect combination. And in many ways it is. But having done more wine tours that I care to admit, I have a few things to say that most travel guides leave out.
This is the honest version.
I’ve written about the highlights of Tuscany before. If you want the full regional breakdown start there. Discover the Best Places to Visit in Tuscany. This post is something different. This is what I wish someone had told me before I explored the area.
Florence: The One That Actually Delivers
Let me start with the stop on an Italy itinerary that never disappoints. Florence is the real thing. Every single time.
There is something about the first time you stand in front of the Duomo that is hard to describe. It literally stops you in your tracks. The scale of it, the intricate facade, the centuries of intention behind every carved detail. It doesn’t even look real. And yet there it is, standing exactly where it has stood since the 15th century. Only now it is littered with tourist all trying to get that perfect photo.
Florence feels like stepping back in time in a way that few cities in the world can replicate. The streets are narrow and medieval. The art is everywhere and I don’t just mean in the museums but carved into doorways and painted onto ceilings of churches you stumble into by accident. If you’re a history buff, then you already know that Florence was the center of the Renaissance and walking through it you can feel exactly why.
Florence tops the list as one of my favorite stops in Italy. I’ve celebrated a couple of birthdays there over the years and chef still tells everyone about the best gelato in Italy on Ponte Vecchio Bridge. I wrote all about our foodie adventures in Discover the Best Things to Eat and Drink in Italy. We go deep on Italian food and this city delivered some of our favorites.
What Florence Does Exceptionally Well
Florence is compact enough to explore almost entirely on foot and every street reveals something worth stopping for. The Ponte Vecchio at sunrise before the crowds arrive. The Piazzale Michelangelo at golden hour with the entire city spread below you. The Mercato Centrale where locals actually shop and the food is genuinely exceptional. You can see history all around you from the horse hooks on the building facades to the bridges that look like a scene from a movie.
The art is without comparison. The Uffizi houses Botticelli’s Birth of Venus and Primavera alongside works by Leonardo, Michelangelo and Raphael. The Accademia holds Michelangelo’s David (the original, not the replica in the Piazza della Signoria). Both are genuinely worth your time.
The Honest Caveats Nobody Mentions
The crowds are real and they are significant. If a visit to Florence Italy is on your summer itinerary, prepare yourself.
Florence is one of the most visited cities in Europe and in the peak summer months you are practically shoulder to shoulder with other visitors. The road leading to the Ponte Vecchio can feel genuinely overwhelming by mid-morning. And let’s not forget the long lines for major attractions like the Uffizi museum which can stretch for hours. People arrive in Florence having dreamed about seeing those paintings for years and discover they cannot get in because tickets are sold out weeks in advance. This is not an exaggeration. In peak season, the Uffizi sells out early and consistently. During my first visit to Florence, I just skipped it altogether.
If Uffizi is on your plan, book your tickets before you book your flights. I mean that literally. The moment your travel dates are confirmed go directly to the official Uffizi website and secure your entry. Not a week before your trip. Not from a third party site charging a premium. The official site, the moment you know your dates.
If the lines at Uffizi turn you off, the consider the Accademia instead. It is less crowded, equally extraordinary and the experience of standing in front of the actual David is one that will stay with you long after everything else from the trip has faded.
One more thing about Florence that changed how I experience it. I love a quiet morning walk and this city is different at 7 AM than it is at 11 AM. The early morning belongs to the Florentines. This is when you’ll find shopkeepers opening their shutters, residents walking to the market, the streets still quiet enough that you can hear your own footsteps on the cobblestones. That version of Florence is significantly better than the tourist version.
Recommendation: Stay a minimum 3 nights in Florence and if wine tasting in Tuscany is on your list make it 4 nights. It is your cultural anchor for this Italy itinerary and it rewards time. Do not rush it.
Sorrento: A Beautiful Base That Gets Oversold as a Destination
This is not a popular opinion but Sorrento on your Italy itinerary, I believe it is overrated as a destination.
I want to be precise about what I mean because the view from Sorrento is genuinely beautiful. The Bay of Naples spread before you with Vesuvius in the background on a clear day is a sight worth traveling for. The limoncello is excellent. And don’t forget this is lemon country and the locals take it seriously. The sunsets are real and they are magnificent.
But unless sunsets and limoncello are genuinely sufficient to hold your attention for multiple days, Sorrento runs out of things to do faster than its reputation suggests.
The city is compact. Very compact. The main shopping street, the Corso Italia, takes about twenty minutes to walk from end to end. The historic center is charming but small. The piazzas are lovely but they are not endlessly explorable. By day two most visitors have seen what Sorrento has to offer and are either content with that or quietly wondering what else there is.
The Driving Problem
I love a good road trip but the driving in this part of Italy was pretty traumatic.
Driving in and around Sorrento is genuinely challenging. The roads in this part of the Campania region are narrow in ways that are difficult to describe until you are on them. Two cars cannot comfortably pass in many places. Parking is nearly nonexistent in the town center.
The famous drive along the Amalfi Coast (SS163) is one of the most spectacular roads in the world and also one of the most stressful to navigate in a rental car, particularly in summer when it is shared with tourist buses, vespas and pedestrians who have apparently decided the road is optional. We had to abandon navigation on a day drive because there was no way we could fit that car down that street. Thank goodness for a gps that can automatically “reroute” when you miss (or skip) your turn.
If you take nothing else from this post, take this. Do not drive in Sorrento. Do not drive along the Amalfi Coast if you can avoid it.
The public transport in this region is genuinely excellent and eliminates the stress entirely. The SITA buses connect Sorrento to Positano and Amalfi with scenic views that a car would prevent you from fully appreciating. Leave the car at your hotel and use your feet and the water.
What Sorrento Is Actually Good For
What Sorrento does exceptionally well is serve as a base. It’s where I stayed during my visit to the region. If you get a hotel on the outskirts of the city, you can park your car there and only drive when you are ready to leave.
The logistics of this part of Italy are significantly easier with Sorrento as your anchor. The ferry connections to Capri are frequent and reliable. The bus and ferry connections along the Amalfi Coast to Positano, Amalfi and Ravello are manageable. And if Pompeii or the city itself is on your list, hop on the train. It takes about 30 minutes.
The town has genuine charm when you approach it correctly. A long dinner in one of the restaurants overlooking the bay. A sunset from one of the beautiful villas where views are free and extraordinary.
One evening in Sorrento properly experienced is worth having. Two or three nights with day trips as the primary activity is the correct way to approach it.
Recommendation: 2 to 3 nights in Sorrento. Stay for the sunsets.
Capri: Worth Every Euro, Worth Every Crowd
And then there is Capri. I must admit, I only spent one full day in Capri and boy do I wish I had stayed longer. We definitely did not plan this part of our Italy itinerary well.
Capri is the one that earns its legendary status completely. The island is extraordinary. There is no other word for it. The water surrounding it is a color of blue that your phone camera cannot capture accurately. The views from the upper town, from the chairlift to Monte Solaro, from any point along the coastal path will stop you in ways that are difficult to articulate.
Once you get your bearings, spend some time in the Piazzetta (city center). This is arguabley one of the greatest people-watching spots in the world. Sit with a coffee and watch the world pass for an hour or so. It costs almost nothing and it is genuinely one of the finest ways to spend a morning in Italy.
If you have time, head out to the Blue Grotto. This is definitely one for the tourist in you but that blue water that you’ll see for that few moments in that cave is a thing of beauty.
The Crowds Are Real
July and August in Capri are genuinely overwhelming. Not to mention it can get really hot. If your Italy itinerary includes sweating out your t-shirt, then go in summer.
The funicular from Marina Grande to Capri town fills constantly. I actually took the bus up but even the buses to Anacapri have queues that extend well down the street. Once you make it to the top, you have to fight off other tourist to earn pole position for that perfect photo.
The key is to stay on the island overnight (if the hotel prices don’t scare you) or arrive early to enjoy the quieter early morning and late afternoon when the island returns more fully to the people.
Midday can be chaotic. This is when the day-trippers are at their peak. Every store is full. Every restaurant is booked and just finding a spot for a coffee is a challenge.
If your Italy itinerary includes doing Capri as a day trip from Sorrento, take the first available ferry, go straight to the Blue Grotto, spend the middle of the day on a boat tour around the island while the town is most congested, and return to the Piazzetta in the late afternoon when the day-trippers are heading back to the mainland. That sequence turns a potentially frustrating experience into an excellent one.
Recommendation: Give Capri a full day. Anyone who spends four rushed hours on Capri and says it is overpriced and crowded has done it wrong. The island rewards time and the right timing.
The Itinerary That Actually Works
After a few visit, I am definitely not a self proclaimed expert. But I’ve learned a few things over the years that could be helpful to you.
Florence — 3 nights minimum.
This is your cultural anchor. Book the Uffizi or the Accademia before you book anything else. Do not plan to drive in Florence. I took the train in and didn’t pick up my rental car until the day I was leaving. Spend your mornings at the major sights before the crowds build and your afternoons in the neighborhoods that the tour groups don’t reach. San Miniato al Monte for the view. The Oltrarno neighborhood for the local restaurants. Wander into the restaurant where the locals appear to be eating at grandma’s kitchen. That’s where you’ll find the good stuff.
The drive south through Tuscany to Sorrento — treat this as part of the trip.
If you are collecting a rental car in Florence, use the drive south not as a logistics exercise but as an experience. The Tuscan countryside between Florence and the south is extraordinary. Stop in a hilltop town like San Gimignano or Siena. Drink the wine and have lunch somewhere with no English menu. The drive takes the better part of a day done properly and that is exactly how long it should take. Your Italy itinerary won’t be complete without it.
Sorrento — 2 to 3 nights.
Use it as a hub not a destination. One full day for Capri taking the first ferry, get out to the Blue Grotto immediately on arrival, boat tour in the middle of the day, Piazzetta in the late afternoon. One day to take the bus or ferry to Positano and spend the day getting lost in the city. Take it easy with one evening in Sorrento itself. Catch the sunset, enjoy a good dinner, and finish up with a proper limoncello. That is the correct amount of Sorrento.
Honorable Mention for Your Italy Itinerary
Pompeii is extraordinary. The idea that an entire community was decimated and even remnants of their meals are still in place is fascinating. It also deserves a full dedicated day to experience properly. Most people tack it on as a rushed half-day between Sorrento and something else and come away feeling vaguely cheated. If Pompeii is important to you give it its own day or save it for a separate trip to Naples. A two-hour visit to one of the most significant archaeological sites in the world does it no justice.
My Perspective
This is one of the best trips you can take in Europe. I know that I will definitely go back again and again. Each time I’ll linger a little longer in some of the off the beaten path spots.
But this is an Italy itinerary that punishes the traveler who rushes it. Too little time in Florence means missing the early morning version of the city that most people never see. Too much time in Sorrento means running out of things to do. Capri done wrong produces the kind of “I don’t see what all the fuss is about” reaction that sends people home underwhelmed.
Done right and with enough time, this is the type of trip that you’ll call extraordinary. Florence will make you feel things you didn’t expect. The Amalfi Coast will stop you repeatedly with views that don’t seem real. Capri will make you understand why this small island has drawn artists, writers, emperors and billionaires for centuries.
The Italy of your imagination is real. You just have to approach it correctly.
Heading to Italy? Read these next:
- Discover the Best Places to Visit in Tuscany — the full regional guide including the wine country drive
- Discover the Best Things to Eat and Drink in Italy — what to eat, where it originated and why it matters
- How to Eat Like a Local When You Travel Internationally — the strategy that applies everywhere, including Italy
- Beyond the Resort: How to Travel Like a Local Internationally — why how you experience a destination matters as much as where you go
Frequently Asked Questions
How many days do you need for a Florence, Sorrento and Capri itinerary? A minimum of 8 to 10 days gives you enough time to experience each destination properly. 3 nights in Florence, 1 to 2 nights for the drive south through Tuscany, and 2 to 3 nights in Sorrento as your base for the Amalfi Coast and Capri. Anything shorter and you will spend most of the trip feeling rushed.
Is it worth staying in Sorrento or should I stay in Positano instead? Sorrento is the more practical choice for most travelers. It has better transport connections like ferries to Capri, buses along the Amalfi Coast, trains to Naples. And it is generally more affordable than Positano. Positano is more romantic and the views are extraordinary, but the logistics are more complicated and getting in and out adds friction to every day trip. If budget is not a concern and the Amalfi Coast aesthetic is central to why you are doing this trip, Positano is worth the premium. For most travelers, Sorrento is the smarter base.
When is the best time to visit Capri to avoid crowds? May, early June, September and October offer the best balance of good weather and manageable crowds. July and August are peak season and the island is genuinely overwhelming at midday. If you are visiting in summer take the first ferry of the morning, go directly to the Blue Grotto on arrival and use a boat tour to spend the middle of the day at sea while the town is most congested.
Do I need a car for this Italy itinerary? A car is useful for the Tuscany portion of the trip. Particularly for exploring the countryside, hilltop towns and wine region. For Florence and the Sorrento/Amalfi Coast section, a car creates more problems than it solves. Do not drive in Florence. Do not drive along the Amalfi Coast if you can avoid it. Use ferries, hydrofoils and buses for the coastal section. The public transport is excellent and the views are better without your hands on a wheel.
How do I get from Florence to Sorrento? The most common route is by train from Florence to Naples (approximately 3 hours on the high-speed Frecciarossa service) followed by a Circumvesuviana regional train from Naples Centrale to Sorrento (approximately 1 hour). Alternatively, I recommend for anyone who wants to experience Tuscany properly to rent a car in Florence and drive south through the Val d’Orcia and Campania, treating the journey itself as part of the experience. The drive takes a full day done properly but I’d stay longer.
Is the Blue Grotto in Capri worth it? The Blue Grotto is a brief experience that costs more than it probably should. The light inside the cave is genuinely unlike anything else you will see. Go first thing in the morning to avoid the queues that build throughout the day. If you arrive at midday in July and wait two hours to spend five minutes inside, you will feel the price more acutely. Go early and you will feel only the light.
Discover more from TwoBlackTravelers
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
